It's that time again. Please list your "TOP FIVE" current favorites (daily rotation smokes) for all of us to read. I'll start...
C&D's Green River Vanilla (Flue-Cured Green River Burley Aromatic Vanilla/Honey)
Uhle's Bishop's Move (Full English lots of Latakia)
C&D's Gentleman Callers (Virginia and Burley with lots of Deer Tongue - A completely natural Aromatic Blend)
C&D's Pot O' Gold Mixture (My Own Mixture) Virginia/Burley/Turkish/Maple Red Cavendish. Available directly from C&D by asking for "Captain Bob's Pot O' Gold Mixture" Or, you can mix it yourself: 3 parts Two Friends Heritage; 2 parts Riverboat Gambler; 1 part Autumn Evening.
C&D's Captain Bob's Blend (Personally, my number one favorite) Light English. Unique character, taste and aroma. Light Latakia and Perique combined with four Virginia, Burley and Turkish tobacco's.
What are your current top five favorites?
My 5 this week (This is not as easy as it looks)
Solani Silver Flake
Solani 633
SG FVF
C&D Burley Flake #2
GLP Maltese Falcon
It's winter, so they're fuller than usual:
Boswell Northwoods
Stokkebye Navy Flake
S&G Balkan Flake
McClelland's St. James Woods
Peterson's Irish Flake
Summertime here so it's mainly Va blends (I save the English & variants for winter, when it becomes a lat fest). This is currently what I have open & am dipping into daily AND rate as the Top 5:
SG Full Virginia Flake
Orlik Golden Sliced
McConnell Scottish Cake
Hamborger Veermaster
Rattray's Old Gowrie
McConnell Scottish Cake & Hamborger Veermaster are from my Try-It list. I'm really enjoying these two & will be ordering more.
If you asked what my top 30 were, then maybe.
In order of importance -
Briar and Bean - Gentleman Jack
C&D - Captain Bob's Blend (although I am out)
C&D - Pipe Dreams
Unknown - English Oriental (bulk blend at Briar and Bean but I doubt they make it)
McClelland Red Cake
Those would be:
Prince Albert
Carter Hall
Edgeworth Ready Rubbed
McClelland 5125
Peretti's 333
based on the last month or so (the OGS reserve is very low, so last month I haven't smoked it much, but it's always a favorite)
TF Heritage
C&D Red Carpet
Dunhill My Mixture 965
SG Squadron Leader
GH Rum Flake
Penzance, Black Mallory, Balkan Supreme or Saseni, Black Watch and Westminster but who's counting......Charring Cross, PS Proper English, Engine 99, etc, etc, etc. and then there is always the jar of whatever is left over and all mixed up. In my case it's a mixture of all McClelland areros that contain nuts, chocolate, pastry and coffee (my local bakery) varieties. Sorry Captain if I just screwed up the count. I'm like the mouse. Just five choices is too tough a call for this guy.
for a guy who only smokes one tobacco... :)
Obviously:
McC 2015
McC St James Woods
McC dark Star
McC 2010
Escudo (the orginal version).
Ashtons Black Parrot was a great smoke but I cannot get it anymore... :(
Don’t have a lot on hand and I’m still finding new favorites every time I try a new tobacco.
Windy City Blend (local B&M)
London Bridge
Frog Morton on the Town
Frog Morton on the Bayou
Plumcake
And whatever else I have opened
All C&D blends for me...
OJK
Morleys Best
Miss. Mud
Epiphany
Billy Bud
Prince Albert
Peter Stokkebye Luxury Navy Flake
Peter Stokkebye Luxury Twist Flake
MacBaren Vanilla Creme
Kentucky Club Mixture
... and, all great choices of tobacco, too! We have some very refined pipe smoker's in this crowd. I am so very proud of all of us all! Perhaps there will be even more responses over the next few days.
Thank you for the fantastic response. It is wonderful to see what everybody is enjoying.
Yours truly,
Captain Bob (the skier!)

Ok, BobB, now lets have a pic of you and your tennis racket!
Frog Morton
Jeanies Florence
McClelland Deep Hollow
Half and Half
Carter Hall
It's a new week
Kendal Kentucky
Chelsea Morning
Good Morning
Charing Cross
Sweet Rum Twist
Mine are (in no order)
*Peterson University Flake
*Peterson Irish Whiskey
*Mick McQuaid Plug
*Peterson Merry Xmas 2009
*Peterson Old Dublin
See a pattern at all? (it may be boring, but I love them)
Adios!
1 TF Heritage hands down
2 C&D Green River Vanilla
3 WO Larsen blend #50 no longer available
4 C&D Autumn Evening
5 Pease Kensington
Milan's Wall Street
McC Dark Star
Squadron Leader
Milan's Black Forest
Nording Retriever
Honorable mention to McC 2015
Prince Albert ( Do you have Prince Albert in a can?, How can he breathe in there?)
Penzance (Now that I finally got it open I'm really enjoying it)
Full Va Flake
Stokebe Luxury curly cut
Brown Bogy XX
I also like Orlik Golden Sliced and Brebbia Latakia#9 when I can find them.
Mine are running as follows:
McCranie's 9 to 5
SG Brackan Flake
C&D Opening Night
SG 1792
SG FVF
(With some Kendal Cream thrown in sporadically, my one must have tobacco)
Just like Mouse I have many going, but thus far this week it's been:
SG Brown #4 Twist
SG St. James Flake
Orlik Golden Sliced
4noggins Down By The River
C&D Halav U' Dvash ( Milk and Honey ) it's a blend from Rabbi Ira Stone & William Serad.
Jack
This is close to what my list has looked like for 20+ years the big exception is I have replaced a lot of my consumption of the bulk EMP with AMP and I have cut way back on smoking the CA which doesn't bother my wife at all.
1. EMP(bulk) 40% of the time (aprox.)
2. McC AM Pipe(bulk) 30%
3. 1Q or Dunhill MM A21,000(bulk) 20%
4. My Own Mixture (5:1, cedar aged) PS Balkan Supreme/Cigar 5%
5. Crown Achievement (bulk) 5%
... nice pic.
sg 1792
Boswell Christmas Cookie
GL Pease Robusto
C&D Autum Evening
Brebba Latakia Flake no 9
C&D Plantation Evening
C&D Epiphany
Boswell's Magnum Blend
Peretti's BPC
PS Balkan Supreme
Next week the list could be different, I can be a fickle smoker.
in this order.
1. My Own Blend #222 Flake (Paul Olsen)
2. W.O Larsen Shamrock
3. Orlik Golden Sliced
4.Mac Baren Virginia Flake
5. Mac Baren Virginia Blend.
Summer is Va time for me. Here are 5 favourites I have open:
FVF
Rattrays Old Gowrie
Brown Clunee
Hal O' The Wynd
G&H Best Brown #2
Mine is going to be pretty run of the mill:
Half and Half
Walnut
Carter Hall
MacB Navy Flake
Dunhill Early Morning Pipe
I love em though.
He that can have patience can have what he will.
-Benjamin Franklin